Skip to content
Back to the Journal

Criminal DefenseArticle in English6 min read

Is hiring a private criminal defense lawyer in Tampa worth it?

A detective wants an interview, a court date is approaching, or a family member offers to pay for a lawyer. Here’s how to decide what private representation would add to your defense.

A lawyer points to a document while a client follows along at a wooden table, with palm trees visible through the office window.

If a Tampa detective wants to interview you tomorrow and you have no lawyer, hiring private counsel gives you a chance to ask what the detective wants and get advice before you decide whether to speak. If you already have a Hillsborough County public defender who has requested the evidence, discussed your options, and prepared for your next hearing, staying with that attorney may make good sense. A consultation is still an option if you want a second opinion about a specific issue.

Before spending money, ask what work needs to happen next, who will do it, and what the fee covers. Here’s how those questions play out in a Florida criminal case.

Private attorney or public defender in Hillsborough County?

Both can investigate a charge, challenge evidence, negotiate with the prosecutor, and represent you at trial. The Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office has investigators and legal support staff. A private firm may have those resources in-house or hire them separately. If your case depends on video, a witness, or a lab result, ask how the lawyer would investigate it and who would cover the expense. Hillsborough County Public Defender’s Office.

What matters to youPublic defenderPrivate defense attorney
Choosing a lawyerThe office assigns a lawyer once counsel is appointed.You can meet with lawyers and ask who would personally handle your case.
Getting help earlyEligible people can receive appointed counsel after being taken into custody, including before formal charges are filed.You can hire a lawyer during an investigation, even before an arrest.
Knowing the costFlorida sets financial eligibility rules. An application fee and other court-assessed costs may apply.The fee agreement sets the price, the stages covered, and how additional expenses are handled.
Getting updatesAsk your assigned attorney how to reach the defense team before your next hearing.Before signing, ask who returns calls, reviews evidence with you, and appears in court.

Florida Rule of Criminal Procedure 3.111 on appointment of counsel · Florida law on eligibility and application fees.

How do I request a public defender in Tampa?

If you cannot afford a lawyer, tell the judge at your first appearance that you want to request one. In Hillsborough County, the clerk’s form is called the Application for Criminal Indigent Status. It asks for income, assets, debts, and other financial information. Both the type of case and your financial circumstances matter. Find the Criminal Indigent Application on the clerk’s forms page.

Florida law uses an income threshold of 200% of the federal poverty guidelines for your household size and also recognizes certain benefits, including Supplemental Security Income (SSI) and TANF cash assistance. The clerk considers assets under the statutory rules. The application fee is $50. If you qualify, inability to pay it cannot keep you from receiving appointed counsel. If the clerk finds you ineligible, you can ask the judge to review that decision at your next scheduled hearing. Florida Statute § 27.51 · Florida Statute § 27.52.

When does paying for a private lawyer make the most sense?

When someone asks for a police interview before an arrest. Tell the lawyer who contacted you, what they asked, and when they expect an answer. Counsel can advise you about giving a statement and communicate with investigators on your behalf. You can find out whether a firm will handle just this stage and what changes if charges follow.

When evidence could disappear. Suppose a nearby business has a camera facing the parking lot where an alleged battery occurred. The immediate task is to identify the camera, pin down the time, and request preservation before the recording is overwritten. If you have counsel, give them the location and approximate time promptly. If you’re interviewing a private lawyer, ask who could make that request and when.

When a plea could affect more than the sentence. For someone who holds a professional license or is concerned about immigration status, “no jail time” may answer only one question. Before accepting an offer, ask what the exact plea would mean for you and whether another attorney needs to review it. If you already have a public defender who is addressing that issue, ask a prospective private lawyer what additional work they propose.

How much does a private criminal defense lawyer in Florida cost?

For a rough budgeting reference, a 2025 fee guide published by Florida firm Fighter Law estimated $2,500 to $10,000 for a misdemeanor and $5,000 to $25,000 or more for a felony. Those are one firm’s published estimates. Casagrande Law would need to assess your case to quote a fee. The charge, the volume of evidence, and whether a case goes to trial all affect the work involved. Published fee estimates · The Florida Bar’s guide to attorneys’ fees.

A flat fee can cover different amounts of work. For example, one quote might end when plea negotiations finish, while another includes jury selection and trial. If you’re comparing two quotes, ask each lawyer for written answers to the following questions.

  • What starts now? Does the fee cover the investigation before charges, the first hearing, and review of the evidence?
  • What happens if I go to trial? Does the quoted fee cover trial preparation and trial itself? If there’s a separate fee, when is it due?
  • Which expenses could I owe? Ask who pays for an investigator, expert witness, testing, or transcripts, and whether you approve those costs in advance.
  • Who will represent me? Ask who will handle hearings, go over a plea offer with you, and answer questions between court dates.

Talk with a Tampa criminal defense attorney

Grace Casagrande represented more than 700 clients as an assistant public defender in Orange County before entering private practice. If you’re weighing your options in Hillsborough County, bring your court notice, the charge or case number if you have one, and any deadline a detective or prosecutor gave you. Start the conversation with the decision you need to make first. Read Grace Casagrande’s background.

Call the Tampa office at 813-563-3163. Casagrande Law answers calls 24/7 in English and Spanish. Request a consultation in Tampa.

Consultation

Speak directly with your attorney.

Calls answered 24/7. Service in English and Spanish.